21 October 2026

Portuguese Constitutional Court finds basis for valuation of renewable energy assets unconstitutional

  • In Decision No. 777/2026, issued 24 September 2026, the Portuguese Constitutional Court held that the legal framework underpinning the valuation of wind farms through the cost-based valuation method is unconstitutional, thereby calling into question the basis on which the corresponding municipal property tax liabilities have historically been determined.
  • The decision may provide taxpayers with a meaningful opportunity to challenge historic property valuations and seek the recovery of municipal property tax assessed on the basis of those valuations.
  • The decision's implications may extend beyond the renewable energy sector to other categories of assets subject to the same valuation framework.
  • Although the judgment was rendered in the context of a specific constitutional review proceeding and does not have generally binding effect, it could play a significant role in future disputes involving the application of this valuation methodology and may reinforce taxpayers' positions in ongoing and future litigation.
 

The Portuguese Constitutional Court (Court) has held (Decision No. 777/2026, issued 24 September 2026) unconstitutional the provision that has traditionally served as the legal basis for determining the property tax value (PTV) of renewable energy generation facilities, which is based on a cost-based valuation approach combined with the value of the underlying land (special methodology).

The Court has thus raised fundamental questions regarding the legal framework that has long served as the basis for determining the PTV of renewable energy generation assets. As a result, the decision may provide taxpayers with grounds to challenge valuations carried out under this special methodology, as well as the corresponding municipal property tax (MPT) assessments.

The judgment is particularly noteworthy given that the Portuguese Tax Authorities (PTA) recently reaffirmed their position that wind and solar power generation facilities should be valued pursuant to this special methodology through Circular No. 4/2026, issued on 27 July 2026.

Case background

In this case, the taxpayer challenged the use of the special methodology in valuing its wind farm. In the initial proceedings, the Penafiel Administrative and Tax Court ruled in favor of the taxpayer and declined to apply the special methodology. The Penafiel Administrative and Tax Court reasoned that the Code provision authorizing the special methodology violated the constitutional principle of tax legality, because it left the determination of whether the methodology applied to the discretion of the tax administration or regulations.

Court analysis

In its decision, the Court considered that the law neither identifies the categories of properties subject to the special valuation methodology nor establishes the essential criteria for determining their taxable value. According to the Court, these are fundamental elements of the tax framework and, as such, should be established directly by legislation rather than through administrative regulation.

Accordingly, the Court concluded that the existing framework fails to comply with the constitutional requirements arising from the principle of tax legality.

Implications

The implications of the judgment may extend well beyond renewable energy generation facilities. The Government regulation at issue also covers a number of other asset categories subject to the same valuation methodology, including sports stadiums, golf courses, campsites, dams and fuel stations. Thus, this decision may be relevant for owners of assets in other categories that fall within the scope of the same valuation regime, particularly if their PTV has likewise been determined by reference to the cost-based methodology.

However, the decision was rendered in the context of a specific constitutional review procedure and therefore does not amount to a declaration of unconstitutionality with generally binding effect.

Affected taxpayers should consider, depending on their particular circumstances:

  • Revisiting historic property valuations carried out under the special methodology, as well as any valuation procedures that are currently underway
  • Reviewing opportunities to recover MPT previously assessed and paid
  • Analyzing the broader implications of this case law for future valuations, ongoing disputes and forthcoming MPT assessments
* * * * * * * * * *
Contact Information

For additional information concerning this Alert, please contact:

Ernst & Young, S.A., International Tax and Transaction Services, Portugal

EY Law, Portugal

Published by NTD’s Tax Technical Knowledge Services group; Andrea Ben-Yosef, legal editor

Document ID: 2026-2243